2024 New Jersey Scholarship Winner

Krrisha Patel

Rising E-Scooter Use: Addressing Safety and Liability in Urban Environments

"What if you could zip through city traffic, dodge the morning rush, and reduce your carbon footprint, all while having fun?" This question perfectly captures the allure of electric scooters (e-scooters) that have quickly transformed urban transportation.

The Rise of E-Scooters

E-scooters have surged in popularity, becoming a staple in urban transportation. They are convenient, affordable, and eco-friendly, offering a quick and efficient way to travel short distances. However, this rapid growth has brought new safety and legal challenges.

Safety Concerns

The increase in e-scooter usage has led to a rise in accidents. Studies show that head injuries account for 40% of e-scooter injuries treated in emergency rooms (Trivedi et al., 2019). Lack of helmet use, unpredictable riding behavior, and inadequate infrastructure contribute to these risks.

Liability Issues

Determining liability in e-scooter accidents is complex. Factors such as rider negligence, manufacturer defects, and city infrastructure all play a role. In the case of Sabetian v. Bird Rides, Inc. (2020), a California court ruled that rental companies could still be held liable under certain circumstances.

Legal Framework

The laws governing e-scooters vary by city. For example, California’s Assembly Bill 1112 set helmet requirements and speed limits, but critics argue that more stringent regulations are needed to ensure safety.

Potential Solutions

1. Improved Infrastructure

Dedicated e-scooter lanes and better road conditions can reduce accidents caused by poor infrastructure.

2. Mandatory Safety Training

Requiring users to complete a brief safety course before renting an e-scooter can ensure responsible riding.

3. Stricter Liability Regulations

Implementing mandatory insurance for e-scooter rentals and clear liability guidelines can protect both riders and pedestrians.

4. Public Awareness Campaigns

Educating riders on helmet use, traffic rules, and pedestrian safety through community outreach and digital campaigns can help prevent accidents.

Case Studies

Santa Monica, California

Santa Monica launched a pilot program including designated parking zones, speed limits, and improved infrastructure. While the program reduced accidents, issues like improper parking persisted.

Paris, France

Paris imposed strict regulations, requiring companies to obtain permits and enforce parking rules. These measures significantly improved safety and order.

The Future of E-Scooters

As e-scooters continue to grow in popularity, cities must balance convenience with safety. Innovations like geofencing and AI-powered diagnostics can help improve compliance and reduce risks. Public-private partnerships between cities and e-scooter companies can further enhance safety and sustainability.

References

• California Legislature. (2019). Assembly Bill No. 1112.
• Trivedi, T. K., et al. (2019). Injuries associated with standing electric scooter use. JAMA Surgery.
• Sabetian v. Bird Rides, Inc., No. 19-cv-01057 (C.D. Cal. filed Jan. 17, 2020).
• Yang, J., Finkelstein, S., & Ning, P. (2020). Analyzing e-scooter related injury trends.
• Ralph, K. M., & Lyons, W. (2020). The use of shared e-scooters in urban areas.
• Montgomery, R. W. (2021). Legal challenges of e-scooter regulations.
• National Association of City Transportation Officials (NACTO). (2019). Guidelines for shared active transportation.